The Caning of Charles Sumner occurred after congressman Charles Sumner delivered a fiery speech titled “The Crime Against Kansas” that criticized slaveholders and the institution of slavery. It was symbolic of the mood of the country where civil discourse had become impractical and often led to physical altercations.
Caning of Charles Sumner: Prelude
- In 1856, during the “Bleeding Kansas” crisis, Charles Sumner made a passionate speech that spoke out against the Kansas-Nebraska Act which laid an argument for the admission of Kansas as a free state immediately. He went on to completely denounce slavery in the south.
- After attacking the institution, Sumner turned his attention to Stephen Douglass and Andrew Butler, the authors of the Act.
- Sumner’s speech drew a negative response by many southern and northern congressman. Many did not like how crude he was in his speech or how derogatory he was towards his fellow congressman.
Caning of Charles Sumner: Attack
- Two days after Sumner’s speech, Brooks along with his other congressmen waited in the Senate chamber for everyone to leave. After everyone left, Brooks and his allies walked up to Sumner who was writing at his desk and said, “Mr. Sumner, I have read your speech twice over carefully. It is a libel on South Carolina, and Mr. Butler, who is a relative of mine.”
- In response, Charles Sumner began to get out of his seat but was met with a thick cane across his head. Brooks continued to swing at Sumner and the shocked congressman lost his sight.
- Sumner fell to the floor and was trapped under his bolted desk. He was able to squirm and get loose from the desk, but the entire time he kept taking shots from Brooks’ cane. He stumbled into the aisle with blood dripping from his head and eventually collapsed.
- Congressman tried to help Sumner but was blocked by Brooks’ buddies.
- Brooks continued his pummeling of Sumner and was finally restrained by other Congressman. He left the chamber quietly.
- Sumner regained consciousness and received medical attention. He returned to his lodging where he received additional medical attention.
- Congressman Brooks was charged with assault
Caning of Charles Sumner: Aftermath
- After everything had settled down, Sumner became a martyr in the North and Brooks a hero in the south.
- The northern press argued that the South would not allow free speech and that anyone who disagreed with them would be facing a violence.
- The caning also symbolized how divided the nation was and the rising tensions were beginning to become violent.
- The Crime Against Kansas Speech
- The History Junkie’s Guide to the Civil War
- The History Junkie’s Timeline of the Civil War
- The History Junkie’s Timeline of American History
- The History Junkie’s Guide to Colonial America
- The History Junkie’s Guide to the Revolutionary War
- Slavery during the American Revolution